When Labour published its draft ban on conversion practices in June, one of the quotes in the government’s own press release came from Hilary Cass, the paediatrician whose review reshaped NHS gender care for young people. She said she was “pleased to see that the government is bringing forward legislation.”
This week, she took that back.
The short version
- Who: Baroness Hilary Cass, author of the 2024 Cass Review and now a member of the House of Lords.
- What: She told the joint committee of MPs and peers scrutinising the Draft Conversion Practices Bill that she can no longer support it.
- When: Reported on November 17, 2026, by The Guardian and PinkNews.
- What it means: The bill is still a draft. Nothing changes in law today, and the government says it still wants a ban.
What Cass actually said
According to The Guardian’s report, Cass told the committee: “I can’t support this bill as it has too many problems, including the risk to parents.” She added: “It would have to be radically changed to be workable and I am not sure that is possible.”
Her central worry is about clinicians. She said “the draft bill is already having a chilling effect on healthcare professionals,” and that “standards are hotly disputed in this contentious area and no professional wants to risk complaints and even prosecution.”
She also explained why her name was on the launch press release. “Unfortunately, I was not sent the Bill until about 15 minutes before they wanted the press comment,” she told the committee, per PinkNews. She said her earlier backing was based on conversations with ministers about the bill’s principles, not the full text.
What the bill would actually do
It’s worth being clear about what’s on the table, because the debate can get loud. According to the government’s June announcement, the draft:
- Covers England and Wales.
- Targets abusive acts aimed at changing someone’s sexual orientation or transgender identity that seriously harm the victim.
- Creates offences including carrying out abusive conversion practices and helping to arrange them abroad.
- Adds civil Conversion Practice Protection Orders, modelled on the orders that already exist for forced marriage and FGM.
- Carries penalties of up to five years in prison, an unlimited fine, or both.
- Exempts legitimate healthcare, therapy and counselling.
The government has described this as a “high threshold for criminality,” aimed only at abusive acts that cause “real harm,” The Guardian reports. We broke down the full draft back in July: After Eight Years of Promises, England and Wales Finally Have a Conversion Therapy Bill.
Criticism from both directions
Cass isn’t the only critic, and the criticism doesn’t all point the same way.
On one side, religious leaders and a former head of Britain’s rights watchdog have called for the bill to be dropped, and opponents argue harmful practices are already covered by existing law, according to The Guardian. Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch called the ban “unworkable” earlier this month, PinkNews reported.
On the other side, LGBTQ+ campaigners have spent months arguing the draft is too weak. When it was published, QueerAF reported that TransActual warned the healthcare exemption “paves the way for a cottage industry of conversion abusers posing as therapists and healthcare practitioners,” because almost anyone in the UK can call themselves a therapist. Saba Ali, chair of the Ban Conversion Practices Coalition, said at the time that “publication is not the finish line, it is where the hard work truly begins.”
So the same exemption Cass thinks is not tight enough to protect clinicians is the one trans groups think is too loose to protect them.
Who’s still backing it
The bill still has serious professional support. Dr Igi Moon, a psychologist speaking for a coalition of more than 25 health, counselling and psychotherapy organisations that signed a memorandum of understanding to end conversion practices, gave evidence in favour. Their message to the committee was simple: “We want a legal ban,” per The Guardian.
And the government isn’t backing off. A spokesperson told the BBC it would take the committee’s evidence seriously because it wants “to get this ban right.”
What happens next
The draft is in pre-legislative scrutiny. That means a joint committee of MPs and peers hears evidence (its first oral session was on October 29), then writes a report with recommendations. Only after that would the government introduce a final bill for Parliament to debate and vote on.
In other words: Cass’s withdrawal is a real blow to the bill’s political cover, but it isn’t a vote and it isn’t the end. The committee’s report, and whether ministers tighten or loosen the healthcare exemption in response, is the next thing to watch.
Why this matters
UK governments have promised to ban conversion practices since 2018. Eight years later, LGBTQ+ people in England and Wales still have no specific legal protection from them. Scotland and Northern Ireland handle this separately (we covered Northern Ireland’s bill in September).
What happens in this committee will decide whether England and Wales end up with a ban that protects people, a ban riddled with loopholes, or no ban at all. That’s worth paying attention to, calmly and loudly.