Some good news out of Istanbul, with a big asterisk.

On Wednesday, November 18, the first hearing in Türkiye’s case against the LGBTI+ group SPoD ended with two of its founders walking free after more than two months in pretrial detention. The case itself, including the push to dissolve one of Istanbul’s best-known queer rights organisations, carries on.

We covered the indictment last week. Here’s what happened in court.

The short version

  • Released: Founders Cenk Soyer and Volkan Yılmaz, held since September 16. The judge rejected the prosecutor’s request to keep them in custody.
  • Also: Judicial supervision measures were lifted. Co-defendants Osman Cihan Hüroğlu and Özlem Çolak were not in custody and are standing trial without detention.
  • Still on the table: One to three years in prison for all four, and the dissolution of SPoD.
  • Next hearing: February 12, 2027, at Istanbul’s 27th Criminal Court of First Instance.

That’s per reporting by Agos and bianet, both of which covered the hearing.

What the case is about

The Istanbul Chief Public Prosecutor’s Office filed the indictment on November 2, as part of the “My Family Is Safe” (Ailem Güvende) operations that began on September 12. It accuses the four founders of violating the Law on Associations and claims SPoD’s activities were “contrary to law and morality,” Agos reports.

What’s cited as evidence is, essentially, 15 years of a rights group doing its job: LGBTI+ rights work, activity reports, events, social media posts, solidarity initiatives and foreign donations. The indictment lists more than $1.57 million in foreign funding but, according to Agos, doesn’t identify a specific criminal act or how the money was misused.

It also includes a September 7 inspection report from the Istanbul Governorship. That report noted the group’s premises held publications in several languages, a meeting room with 30 to 35 chairs, and that SPoD held discussions, workshops, book readings and film screenings.

What the defendants said

Soyer and Yılmaz told the court they were detained for helping found the association about 15 years ago, even though they no longer hold management roles. Their lawyers argued the file contains no evidence beyond a police report, and that screening documentaries isn’t a crime.

Cihan Hüroğlu said the association “continues its work in accordance with its bylaws” and asked to be acquitted. His lawyer, Bilge Bilgin, pointed out that the documentary My Child (Benim Çocuğum), cited in the charges, had been shown in cinemas.

Özlem Çolak, a psychologist who works on trauma, said she hasn’t had an administrative role at SPoD since 2011. “There is a gulf between the indictment and reality,” she told the court, per Agos. “I do not understand what I am being accused of.”

She also rejected the indictment’s claim of “propaganda” aimed at young people. Sexual orientation and gender identity, she said, “cannot be changed through propaganda, encouragement or inducement!” And: “What harms children and young people and causes them trauma is the deprivation of their rights.”

Defence lawyer Yelda Koçak Urfa made a sharp point about that inspection report: if the authorities had recorded even the chairs in the room, she said, there was no reason to detain anyone or put them under judicial supervision.

It’s bigger than SPoD

Before the hearing, Esther Major, Amnesty International’s Deputy Regional Director for Europe, said the investigations criminalise human rights advocacy and warned the case could be the start of similar prosecutions, bianet reports.

The Human Rights Defenders Solidarity Network, a coalition of 38 organisations including Amnesty, lists the other cases:

  • HEVİ LGBTİ+: five founders charged in Istanbul
  • Lambdaistanbul: six founders charged in Istanbul
  • Kaos GL (Ankara): 16 board and supervisory board members and a journalist charged

The network has asked that legal and psychosocial support, health access, workshops, meetings and publications stop being treated as grounds for criminal charges.

What to watch

The court has not ruled on whether any crime happened, and it made no decision on dissolving SPoD. Everything moves to February 12, 2027.

For now, two people who spent 64 days in detention for co-founding a rights group are home. That’s worth something, and so is keeping eyes on what comes next.