On November 16, five European governments stood up at a press conference in Vienna and said they want to start sending people to Rwanda. Not their own citizens: people who have been told they have no right to stay in the EU, and who can’t be sent back to their home country.

The countries are Austria, Denmark, Germany, Greece and the Netherlands. The plan is called a “return hub”. For LGBTI people who fled persecution and lost their asylum case, it raises a hard question: what happens when Europe sends you to a country you’ve never lived in, which has no legal protection for who you are?

What was actually announced

According to the Dutch government’s statement, the five countries (the “core group”) and Rwanda are setting up a return hub “as an alternative” when return to someone’s country of origin can’t be carried out.

The key details so far:

  • Who: people without a right to stay in the EU who have an enforceable return decision. Unaccompanied minors are excluded.
  • First phase: the core group “will only return single men to Rwanda”, the Dutch government says.
  • When: the first transfers are expected in 2027, ECRE reports.
  • Size: the first hub is expected to hold around 100 people at a time as a pilot, Euronews reported.
  • Conditions: people would live in “an open, temporary facility” and could then settle in Rwanda with a right of residence and access to work, education, healthcare and the courts, or go back to their country of origin. The five European countries pay.

Denmark’s Prime Minister Mette Frederiksen said the plan would deter illegal entry, according to Euronews. Rwanda says it will “protect the right to asylum while treating migrants with dignity at every stage.”

Why now: the new EU Return Regulation

This is possible because of a new EU law. The Return Regulation (EU) 2026/2280 entered into force on October 16, ECRE notes. It allows people with no right to stay to be sent to a third country under a “return hub” arrangement, but only once an agreement with that country has been concluded.

That agreement doesn’t exist yet. EUobserver reported there is “no formal deal” and that key details remain secret, according to ECRE’s round-up.

If this all sounds familiar, it should. The UK spent years on its own Rwanda plan, which the UK Supreme Court ruled on in November 2023 after the Court of Appeal found Rwanda was not a safe third country. The EU version is built differently (it targets people already refused, rather than people still waiting for a decision), but many of the same organisations are raising the same alarms.

The LGBTI-specific worries

ILGA-Europe joined 46 other organisations from 16 countries in a joint letter calling on the five governments to drop the plan. Its concerns for LGBTI people are concrete:

  • No legal protection. Rwanda has no equality or non-discrimination protections covering sexual orientation, gender identity, gender expression or sex characteristics, ILGA-Europe says, and legal gender recognition is not possible there.
  • Medication could stop. People could lose access to healthcare, including hormone therapy, antiretroviral (HIV) treatment and SSRIs.
  • Abuse goes unreported. In hostile environments, LGBTI people are less likely to report anti-LGBTI abuse.
  • Onward risk. Return hubs may end up sending people on to countries where LGBTI people are criminalised.

Put simply: a queer man whose asylum claim was refused in Germany, perhaps because officials didn’t believe he was gay, could find himself in a facility in Kigali, far from the community and support he’d built in Europe.

The letter’s sharpest line: “The risks associated with ‘return hubs’ are not implementation failures but are the very purpose of the model.”

A wide wall of criticism

ILGA-Europe isn’t alone. ECRE “strongly condemns” the plan. Amnesty International called it a deal that “repeats mistakes of the past”, and PRO ASYL called it “a human rights disaster waiting to happen”. The Council of Europe’s Secretary General, Alain Berset, has called for return hubs to be “compatible with the European Convention on Human Rights”.

Amnesty’s Olivia Sundberg put the accountability gap plainly to Euronews: “we don’t know who’s legally responsible if something goes wrong.”

What happens next

The core group, Rwanda and international organisations will now work out the details. The Netherlands says it intends to work with UNHCR and the IOM, which already operate in Rwanda.

The things to watch:

  1. The agreement text. Will it screen out people at particular risk, including LGBTI people and people living with HIV? The Dutch statement currently names only unaccompanied minors as excluded.
  2. The courts. Expect legal challenges under the European Convention on Human Rights once transfers become real.
  3. Who else joins. Other EU governments are watching how this pilot goes.

For LGBTI people who came to Europe looking for safety, the most important thing today is that nothing has changed yet. There is time for lawyers, refugee groups and voters to push for protections before 2027.