Paul Mescal doesn’t hold back on question of whether straight actors should play gay roles
Sign up for more LGBTQ+ news and updates at TrueQueer.
Irish actor and internet sensation Paul Mescal has recently shared his thoughts on the portrayal of queer characters in film and television, as well as the debate surrounding whether straight actors should play gay roles. The 27-year-old Normal People star, who is straight, believes that the authenticity and care taken in storytelling should determine the casting of queer characters.
In a recent interview with The Sunday Times, Mescal discussed his upcoming role in the fantasy-romance drama All of Us Strangers, where he plays the character Harry, who is gay. The film, based on Taichi Yamada’s novel Strangers, explores themes of loneliness, grief, and love as two characters find solace in each other. Mescal defended his casting by emphasizing the film’s commitment to authenticity and the passion of its cast and crew.
Mescal expressed his frustration with past portrayals of queer characters in cinema, stating that many of them have been offensive due to the carelessness of filmmakers and actors. However, he believes that All of Us Strangers does not fall into that category and should be judged on its own merits.
His co-star in the film, Andrew Scott, who is openly gay, has also weighed in on the debate. Scott emphasized the importance of both representation and transformation in acting. He argued that actors should not be cast solely based on their sexuality but rather on their ability to portray the attributes of the character. Scott cautioned against a “totalitarian regime” and suggested that each story should be evaluated individually to determine what is right for that particular narrative.
The question of whether straight or cisgender actors should play LGBTQ+ roles has sparked heated discussions within the entertainment industry. Controversies such as Eddie Redmayne’s portrayal of trans painter Lili Elbe in The Danish Girl have raised concerns about whether actors who do not identify with marginalized groups can authentically represent them. There is also a concern that straight actors taking on LGBTQ+ roles may deny opportunities to queer and trans artists who already face marginalization in the industry.
Russell T Davies, the showrunner of Doctor Who and writer/producer of It’s a Sin, has advocated for the casting of gay actors in gay roles. He believes that there is a level of authenticity that can only be achieved by casting LGBTQ+ actors. Davies has stated that while straight actors can play gay roles brilliantly, he feels the need to continue advocating for LGBTQ+ representation because “no one else is saying it.”
On the other hand, Sir Ian McKellen has defended straight actors playing LGBTQ+ roles. He pointed to the film Bent, which educated the world about the Holocaust, as an example of the importance of storytelling and the impact it can have. McKellen believes that there is nothing wrong with straight actors taking on these roles.
During his interview with The Sunday Times, Paul Mescal also discussed the themes of his upcoming film, All of Us Strangers. He described it as a story about men navigating vulnerability and the societal pressures that discourage them from seeking help. Mescal expressed his disdain for influencers like Andrew Tate, whom he believes perpetuate toxic masculinity. He believes that toxic masculinity has had a detrimental effect on society and that redefining masculinity requires difficult but necessary conversations.
In conclusion, Paul Mescal’s comments on the portrayal of queer characters and the casting of straight actors in gay roles highlight the ongoing debate within the entertainment industry. While some argue for authenticity and representation, others believe in the transformative power of acting. Each perspective brings its own merits and challenges, ultimately emphasizing the importance of thoughtful storytelling and consideration for marginalized communities.
Follow us on: Facebook for more LGBTQ+ news and updates at TrueQueer.
