Music fans slam St. Vincent’s ‘terrible’ tribute to late trans producer Sophie
Sign up for more LGBTQ+ news and updates at TrueQueer.
In the world of music, tributes to fallen stars are a common occurrence. When a beloved artist passes away, their impact on the industry and their fans is often commemorated through songs, lyrics, and heartfelt gestures. However, the way in which these tributes are crafted can sometimes spark controversy and debate among fans and critics alike.
Such is the case with St. Vincent’s latest album, “All Born Screaming”, which features a track paying tribute to the late trans DJ and music producer Sophie. Sophie, a Grammy-nominated artist, tragically passed away in January 2021 after a fatal fall from a building in Greece while trying to get a better view of the full moon. The news of Sophie’s death sent shockwaves through the LGBTQ+ music community, prompting an outpouring of grief from fans, fellow artists, and collaborators.
On the track “Sweetest Fruit”, St. Vincent references Sophie’s untimely death with the lyrics: “My Sophie climbed the roof to get a better view of the moon, moon. My God, then one wrong step took her down to the depths, but for a minute, what a view.” While some fans appreciate the sentiment behind the tribute, others feel conflicted about St. Vincent referring to Sophie as “my Sophie” when they never actually met in person.
The controversy surrounding St. Vincent’s tribute to Sophie has sparked a wider conversation about the way in which artists choose to honor their fallen peers. Some fans feel that too many tributes focus on the tragic circumstances of Sophie’s death rather than celebrating her life and impact on the music industry. Singer-songwriter Caroline Polachek also dedicated a song to Sophie last year, but her tribute focused more on Sophie’s work and legacy rather than the details of her passing.
Despite the criticism, St. Vincent defended her decision to include the tribute on her album, explaining that she was moved by the tragic circumstances of Sophie’s death and wanted to pay homage to her in a meaningful way. She described the song as an extension of a jam session and emphasized that she was a fan of Sophie from afar, despite never meeting her in person.
While some fans continue to express their disappointment with St. Vincent’s tribute, others have come to her defense, praising the lyrics as “gorgeous” and arguing that the intention behind the song is clear. As the debate rages on, it is clear that tributes to fallen stars will always be a source of contention in the music industry.
In the coming months, more tributes to Sophie are set to be released, including Charli XCX’s upcoming track “So I”, which focuses on their time working together rather than the circumstances of Sophie’s death. As fans continue to grapple with how best to honor Sophie’s memory, it is clear that her impact on the music world will never be forgotten.
In conclusion, tributes to fallen stars will always be a delicate balancing act between celebrating their life and legacy while also acknowledging the tragic circumstances of their passing. As artists continue to navigate this terrain, it is important for fans and critics alike to approach these tributes with sensitivity and respect for the artists they aim to honor.
Follow us on: Facebook for more LGBTQ+ news and updates at TrueQueer.
tribute
