Gay teacher fired after announcing wedding online loses court appeal
Sign up for more LGBTQ+ news and updates at TrueQueer.
In a recent decision that has sparked controversy and debate, a federal appeals court ruled that a Catholic school in North Carolina was within its rights to fire a gay teacher after he announced his wedding online. Lonnie Billard, a former teacher at Charlotte Catholic High School, had worked at the school for over a decade before being let go in 2012.
The court’s ruling overturned a previous decision that found the school and the Roman Catholic Diocese of Charlotte guilty of violating Billard’s employment protection against sex discrimination. According to Associated Press, the school argued that Billard was not invited back as a substitute teacher because of his public support for same-sex marriage, which conflicted with the teachings of the Catholic Church.
Judge Pamela Harris, announcing the Fourth Circuit Court’s decision, cited the “ministerial exception” to Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which protects religious institutions’ rights to make employment decisions regarding employees who play essential roles in fulfilling their religious missions. In this case, the court determined that Billard’s role as a teacher required him to integrate Catholic teachings into his curriculum, making his advocacy for same-sex marriage incompatible with the school’s mission.
Billard, who taught English and drama at the school, was terminated after announcing his intention to marry his partner following the legalization of same-sex marriage in North Carolina in 2014. He filed a lawsuit against the school in 2017, leading to the recent appeals court decision.
Following the ruling, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) and a Charlotte law firm representing Billard expressed disappointment and concern over the outcome. They characterized the decision as “heart-breaking” and warned that it could set a dangerous precedent for LGBTQ+ workers facing discrimination in the workplace.
Billard’s case has raised questions about the boundaries between religious freedom and anti-discrimination laws. While the school argued that its decision was based on upholding Catholic teachings, critics argue that it sets a dangerous precedent for allowing employers to discriminate against LGBTQ+ individuals under the guise of religious beliefs.
In response to the court’s decision, Billard expressed regret over not being able to continue his career as an educator without fear of discrimination. He emphasized that his identity as a gay man should not have been a factor in his termination and expressed hope that the legal battle would raise awareness about LGBTQ+ rights in the workplace.
Moving forward, Billard has the option to request a rehearing of his case within 14 days or appeal to the Supreme Court within 90 days. The outcome of this case could have far-reaching implications for LGBTQ+ individuals working in religious institutions and highlight the ongoing struggle for equality and acceptance in the workplace.
The controversy surrounding Billard’s case serves as a reminder of the complex intersection between religious beliefs and LGBTQ+ rights. As debates continue over where to draw the line between freedom of religion and protection against discrimination, cases like this one will continue to shape the legal landscape for LGBTQ+ individuals across the country.
Follow us on: Facebook for more LGBTQ+ news and updates at TrueQueer.
Gay teacher
